Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the by Robert F. Weir (auth.), Arthur L. Caplan, Robert H. Blank,

By Robert F. Weir (auth.), Arthur L. Caplan, Robert H. Blank, Janna C. Merrick (eds.)

In April 1982, an little one boy used to be born in Bloomington, Indiana, with Down syndrome and a faulty, yet surgically correctable, esophagus. His mom and dad refused to consent to surgical procedure or intravenous feeding. The clinic unsuccessfully sought a courtroom order to strength therapy, and appeals to raised courts additionally failed. the kid, pointed out as child Doe through the scoop media, for that reason died. The occasions in Bloomington turned the catalyst for motion through the Reagan management, the courts, and Congress that culminated in a federal coverage that makes failure to regard newborns with disabilities a kind of kid forget. This publication facilities at the public coverage points of withholding remedy from significantly unwell newborns who're disabled. particularly, it offers with why the coverage was once enacted and what effect it has had on wellbeing and fitness care employees, households, and babies. a number of the members to this e-book spearheaded the early debate on withholding therapy. Anthony Shaw's big apple occasions journal article in 1972 was once the 1st to deal with those concerns within the well known press. the next 12 months, he released a similar article within the New England magazine of drugs. additionally showing during this related factor of NEJM, was once the pathbreaking research, coauthored through A. G. M. Campbell, on withholding therapy within the unique care nursery at Yale-New Haven clinic. each one of those articles promoted a lot public discussion.

Show description

Read or Download Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the Treatment of Critically Ill Newborns PDF

Similar government books

Twentieth-Century German Political Thought

This publication provides the 1st single-volume evaluation of twentieth-century German political inspiration, emphasizing its variety and contested nature. established chronologically, the ebook covers quite a lot of theorists. issues comprise the character of politics; collective id; the guideline of legislations; the function of the country; the position of political events and the character of parliamentary democracy; kingdom intervention in society and the economic climate; and the foreign order.

Implementing E-Government: Report of the Regional Workshop

E-government is now a vital subject matter in info society in any respect degrees: neighborhood, nationwide, neighborhood or even international. it may be outlined as a metamorphosis of public-sector inner and exterior relationships via use of data and conversation expertise (ICT) to advertise better responsibility of the govt., bring up potency and cost-effectiveness and create a better constituency participation.

The Dynamics of Conflict in Northern Ireland: Power, Conflict and Emancipation

This booklet offers a complete and unique interpretation of the Northern eire clash. It situates the clash firmly in its Irish, British and wider foreign contexts, displaying how the pointy conflicts of curiosity are generated by means of deep-set constructions and family inside of Britain and eire.

Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the Treatment of Critically Ill Newborns

In April 1982, an toddler boy used to be born in Bloomington, Indiana, with Down syndrome and a faulty, yet surgically correctable, esophagus. His mom and dad refused to consent to surgical procedure or intravenous feeding. The health center unsuccessfully sought a court docket order to strength therapy, and appeals to better courts additionally failed.

Additional resources for Compelled Compassion: Government Intervention in the Treatment of Critically Ill Newborns

Example text

Thus began the public debate over the treatment of newborns with disabilities, and over who should have the right and responsibility for making these life-and-death decisions. The debate was thrust onto the public agenda through the intensive efforts of the prolife lobby, which actively pursued allies among disabled citizens rights groups and the medical profession. In light of the Bloomington case-and pressure from the prolife lobby-the Reagan administration notified hospitals that failure to treat such infants was a violation of their civil rights.

Saunders, Philadelphia, pp. 807-822. Young, E. W. D. and Stevenson, D. K (1990) Limiting treatment for extremely premature, low-hirth-weight infants (500 to 750 g). Am. J. Dis. Child. 144,549-552. Conflict, Compromise, and Symbolism The Politics of the Baby Doe Debate Janna C. Merrick In September 1989, the US Civil Rights Commission released its report on medical discrimination against children with disabilities, l finding that its "inquiry leaves no doubt that newborn children have been denied food, water, and medical treatment solely because they are, or are perceived to be, disabled" (Civil Rights, 1989).

Engelhardt, H. T. , (1986) The Foundations of Bioethics (Oxford University Press, New York), p. 117. Feinberg, J. (1984) Harm to Others (Oxford Univerisity Press, New York), p. 96. Feinberg, J. ), Random House, New York, pp. 256-292. Frader, J. ), Indiana University Press, Bloomington, IN, pp. 180-185. Goldman, G. , Stratton, K, and Brown, M. D. (1989) What actually happened: An informed review of the Linares incident. Law, Medicine and Health Care 17,298-307. Gostin, L. (1989) Editor's introduction: Family privacy and persistent vegetative state.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.89 of 5 – based on 26 votes